Switched from Strat to a '60s Tele Custom — board sounds wrong now. Help.

Same pickups (P-90 swap), same amp, same pedals, same room. Tele feels honkier. Is it me, the cap, or do I have to re-voice the whole chain? The Klon is suddenly mid-forward in a way it never was on the Strat. I assumed P-90s would mellow that out, not exaggerate it.