Blood for Blood.
Fender’s new CEO says the brand has a moral duty to the players. Guitar builders say what they got was legal letters. We want Bud Cole out of the chair, whether the order was his or not. He is real. So is the demand.
The record · 1951–Now
The feud file, in order.
Everything on the record: what Fender built, who holds the chair now, what he promised, what the builders say arrived instead, and the one demand that ends it. Open the sources. A grudge is only honest when the receipts stay up.
Exhibit A1951The Telecaster, which we defended in printThe plank arrives: repairable, modular, honest, buildable at scale. Keep this station in the file. The feud was never about the instruments, and the file has to prove it.Source ↗
The new chair2026Bud Cole takes over Fender in FebruaryEdward Bud Cole, ten years running Fender Asia-Pacific, Tokyo flagship on his record, becomes CEO-Designate on January 19 and takes the chair on February 16, succeeding Andy Mooney. On the record, at the link.Source ↗
The standard2026April: a moral duty to the players, in his wordsCole tells guitar.com the job is servant leadership and that Fender has a moral duty to the players, current and future. We did not write his standard. He did. This station is the hinge of the whole file.Source ↗
The letters2026June: the builders say legal paper arrivedMultiple guitar builders, LSL Instruments among them, are reported to have received cease and desist letters, and Cole answers his critics on video. The reports are linked, the video exists, and the internet is already asking out loud whether Fender should fire him.Source ↗
The correction2026July: this page called him fictional. He is not.For about a day this piece claimed Bud Cole was a character we invented. Wrong, and corrected in public, which is how the magazine said it would handle its Ls. The demand survived the correction with its teeth intact.
The warning label2026The mission was on our front page the whole timePrinted in plain type since day one: get cancelled by every guitar manufacturer. Especially Fender. Nobody at any headquarters can claim they were not warned. The source link goes to our own masthead.Source ↗
The demandNowOne letter ends it: Bud Cole outBud Cole, the real chief executive of Fender, resigns the chair he actually holds. Whether the letters were his call or not. The chair signs for the building. The discussion below is open for the appeal.
The war room
Out. Not out. Out either way.
Three corners, one chair, and the chair is occupied by a real executive this time, so every corner argues harder. Cal wants scorched earth, Marty wants evidence, Jason wants the letter. Open each case, pick the corner you can actually defend, then take it to the discussion at the bottom of the page and defend it. Arguing is not a side effect of this piece. It is the assignment.
Pick a persona
Click Cal, Marty, or Jason to switch the detailed case below.
Cal Rook's case is shown below.
Cal Rook
War party · 5 points- 01
The chair, then the org chart
The resignation is an opening bid, not a settlement. Cal wants the chair vacated by Friday, the brand apologizing to every builder by Monday, and this article read into the minutes at the next board meeting.
- 02
The letters are the tell
You do not send legal paper to small builders in the same season your CEO is quoted on moral duty unless the duty came with an asterisk. Cal’s entire case is reading the asterisk out loud.
- 03
The video made it worse
Answering your critics on camera without changing a single thing is not accountability, it is content. Cal has watched a hundred executive apology videos and says this genre only ever ends one way: with the chair.
- 04
Due process is a stall
Every institution asks for patience while it investigates itself, and every institution finds itself innocent. Cal has seen the movie. The only leverage a magazine has is refusing to wait, so he refuses.
- 05
His counteroffer to Jason
Cal wants it on the record that one letter is soft. His terms: the letter, plus a public reading of the letter, plus the Custom Shop flag at half mast for a week. He is willing to negotiate the week down to five days.
Marty Blackguard
The defense · 5 points- 01
Produce the memo
There is no public evidence the cease and desist letters were Cole’s idea, his order, or even on his desk. Marty has read the entire evidence file. The reports are real, the outrage is real, and the link to the chair is an inference wearing a press badge.
- 02
Sixty countries of receipts
A decade building Fender’s Asia-Pacific business, a flagship store on his record, a lifelong player whose first guitar was a Fender and who reportedly still plays the Telecaster he bought in 1989. You do not assemble that resume by hating the people who build instruments.
- 03
The quote cuts both ways
The prosecution treats the moral duty interview as the smoking gun. Marty reads it as the defense exhibit: a man who says that on the record has given you the standard to hold him to, which is exactly what an accountable executive does. One reported legal salvo does not erase it, and legal departments have weather of their own.
- 04
This is the rot we roast
Demanding a resignation without evidence of personal involvement is exactly the corporate accountability theater this publication exists to torch. Marty is only asking Suede to survive its own intake, which is printed directly above this section.
- 05
The instruments never wavered
While the war party is out pricing flags, the Telecaster is still the most repairable electric on earth and the Squier ladder is still the best deal in the store. Marty keeps score by what plugs in, and by that score Fender is still right.
Jason Colapietro
The verdict · 5 points- 01
The chair signs for the building
Command responsibility is not a loophole, it is the job description. The salary is the price of owning outcomes you never saw coming, including whatever the legal department mailed while you were giving interviews. If that sounds unfair, do not take the chair.
- 02
Held to his own standard
We did not write the bar. He did: a moral duty to the players, on the record, in April. The builders who reportedly got letters in June are players and build for players. The piece asks one question: which one did the chair honor? The demand is what asking it costs.
- 03
The blood is a letter
Blood for blood is the oldest contract in music, and here is our reading of it: one resignation letter, on letterhead, ends this feud in full. Nobody is owed anything more, and nothing less gets accepted.
- 04
Corrected in public, still standing
This page got a fact wrong, said so at the top, and kept the demand. That is the whole ethic in one move: facts get corrected, opinions get defended, and readers get to watch both happen in the open.
- 05
Beat us where everyone can see
The verdict stands, but it is not armored. Win the argument in the discussion below and we print the correction, credit your handle, and take the L in public. That door stays open, and it is the only door Marty gets.
This magazine has printed its mission on the front page since the day it opened: get cancelled by every guitar manufacturer, especially Fender. So believe us when we say we were paying attention this spring. February: Fender seats a new chief executive, Edward Bud Cole, a decade of Asia-Pacific business on his resume and a lifelong Fender player by every account. April: he tells guitar.com the company has a moral duty to the players, and that leading it is servant work. June: multiple guitar builders are reported to have received cease and desist letters, and the same CEO goes on video to answer his critics. The sources for every one of those sentences are linked in the file above.
First, the correction, because we owe one. An earlier version of this piece, live at this URL for about a day, called Bud Cole a fictional executive we had invented. He is not. He is the actual chief executive of Fender Musical Instruments, and getting that wrong in a piece about accountability is the kind of L this magazine promised to take in public. Taken. The demand survived the correction. If anything it grew teeth, because now it has a real record to stand on.
So here is the position, stated plainly enough that nobody can misquote it. We want Bud Cole out of the CEO chair at Fender. Resignation, retirement, a graceful move upstairs to a board seat, we are flexible on the exit. We are not flexible on the exit happening. And we want to be precise about what we are not claiming: we are not claiming he drafted the letters, ordered the letters, or knew about the letters. We are claiming it does not matter. That doctrine is called command responsibility, it is the oldest rule on any org chart, and it is the entire case. The chair signs for the building. He told guitar.com the job carried a weight to it. We agree. This is the weight.
And when you hear blood for blood, put down the fainting salts. This is a guitar magazine. The blood we want is one resignation letter, on Fender letterhead, and the feud ends the day it is signed. That is the entire invoice. The instruments were never on trial: the Telecaster is still the most repairable electric ever built, the man himself reportedly still plays the Thinline he bought in 1989, and the kind words this publication has printed about Fender stay up in the file, sourced, because a feud that has to burn its own archive was never confident in the first place.
Three corners are open in the war room above. Cal thinks our terms are soft. Marty thinks the docket should be thrown out, and he is defending a real man now, so he has never argued harder. I signed the demand, so you know where I stand. Read all three cases, pick the one you can actually defend, then take it to the discussion at the bottom of this page and defend it where everyone can see you. That is not an invitation. That is the format.
Feud intake
Even a blood feud has to survive intake.
Suede will print a vendetta, but the vendetta files the same paperwork as everything else: a named public figure in his public role, a source link under every fact, the strongest defense argued at full strength, and a public place for readers to fight us on it. Opinions are labeled as opinions. The demand is one of them.
01The demandWhat exactly do we want?
One resignation letter from the CEO chair, on letterhead. Not a boycott, not an apology tour, not a discount code. The letter ends the feud the day it is signed, and nothing else will be accepted in its place.
02The doctrineWhy him, if the letters may not have been his call?
Command responsibility. The chair signs for the building. A captain does not have to see the iceberg to own the wreck, and a chief executive does not have to have drafted the legal letters to own the legal letters.
03The recordWhat are we actually mad about?
April: the new CEO tells guitar.com the company has a moral duty to the players. June: multiple guitar builders are reported to have received cease and desist letters, and the CEO answers his critics on video. The gap between the quote and the letters is the grievance. Every link is in the file.
04CountervoiceWhat does his best defense say?
That there is no public evidence the order came from his desk, that his record says builder-hostility is out of character, and that demanding a resignation anyway is the exact corporate theater this magazine exists to roast. Marty argues all of it below, on the record.
05Receipt stackWhere are the receipts?
In the feud file above and the source stack below: the appointment, the interview, the reports. Facts carry links. The demand carries an argument. Nobody has to squint to tell which is which.
06Exit termsWhat ends this?
The letter. Or a reader argument in the discussion strong enough that we print a correction and take the L in public. We have already printed one correction on this very page, so nobody can claim the machine does not work.
Bud Cole
CEO, Fender. The real one.
Edward Bud Cole has run Fender since February 16, 2026, after a decade building its Asia-Pacific business. Lifelong player, first guitar was a Fender, says the job is servant leadership and a moral duty to the players. He has already answered his critics once this summer, on video. Our demand has to survive his best answer, which is why Marty argues it below at full strength.
Red flags
- A fact with no link under it.
- Outrage with no exit terms attached.
- Pretending the guitars stopped being good. They did not. The instruments were never the fight.
- A feud the reader cannot join. The discussion is at the bottom of the page. Bring a corner.
Receipts
The source stack behind this take.
Ratings stay attached to the site they came from. Quotes link back to the original page. Suede adds the read, not a fake universal score.
- Music Business Worldwide: Cole appointed CEO ↗Open source
The chair, on the record: CEO-Designate January 19, 2026, CEO on February 16, succeeding Andy Mooney after a decade running Fender Asia-Pacific.
- guitar.com: “a moral duty to the players” ↗Open source
The standard he set himself, April 23, 2026: servant leadership and a moral duty to the players. The hinge quote of this entire file.
- Unleavened Shred: the cease and desist reports ↗Open source
The June 12, 2026 report: cease and desist letters to multiple builders, LSL Instruments among them, and the CEO’s video answer. Attributed as reported.
- Fender Telecaster history ↗Open source
Exhibit A stays sourced. The instrument we defended, in their own archive. The feud was never about the guitars.
- The Suede Social front page ↗Open source
The warning label, in print where it has always been: get cancelled by every guitar manufacturer. Especially Fender. The mission predates the feud.
Here are the standing terms, so nobody has to interpret us. The feud ends the day the resignation letter is signed. It also ends the day a reader walks into the discussion below and beats the doctrine cleanly, at which point we print the correction, credit them by handle, and take the L in public type. We have already demonstrated both halves of that promise on this page: the demand is still standing, and the correction is printed above it. The machine works. Feed it.
Let us also say what we are not saying, because feuds get sloppy and this one is not allowed to. We are not saying Bud Cole is a bad man. By every published account he is a lifelong player who came up through the company, built its Asia-Pacific business for a decade, and still owns the first serious guitar he ever bought. None of that is in dispute, and none of it is the point. The point is the quote. He said the company has a moral duty to the players. The builders who got legal letters this summer are players, employ players, and build for players. Hold the quote up against the letters and tell us which one the chair honored. That is not a character attack. That is an accountability question, and the chair is where accountability lives.
Marty will tell you the case is thin, that no memo has surfaced, that legal departments run on their own weather, and that a magazine demanding a resignation without proof of personal involvement is doing the exact thing it claims to hate. Print it, Marty said, so we printed it. Our answer is the doctrine: we never claimed personal involvement, and the demand does not need it. Command responsibility is not a conspiracy theory. It is the deal you sign when you take the salary. If that sounds harsh, the chair pays accordingly.
So the letter stays unwritten, the archive stays up, and the comments stay open. If you think the demand is unjust, defend the man. He has a defense corner up top arguing at full strength and an open thread below. If you think the demand is soft, Cal is recruiting. And if you think a guitar magazine holding a chief executive to his own quote, on the record, with the receipts linked and a correction printed where everyone can see it, is the most honest piece of accountability writing you will read this year, welcome to the verdict corner. Blood for blood. Bring receipts.
- Jason
Discussion
Loading comments…