How Suede Social works.
Suede Social is a guitar site with three parts: a forum where players ask and answer gear questions, free tools for planning a pedalboard and its power, and a gear desk that checks magazine reviews against the people who bought the gear. This page explains the gear desk.
The problem we are solving
A magazine reviews a pedal around the time it comes out. The reviewer usually has a loan unit for a short while, and the companies that make gear are also the companies that advertise. Of the 212 scored reviews on our desk, 207 got four out of five or better.
The people who pay for the pedal find out the rest later: whether it hums on a shared power supply, whether the footswitch lasts, whether it is still on the board in month three. They post that on retailer pages and forums, scattered and hard to find. We put the two side by side.
The magazines we read
When this site says “the magazines” or “the press”, it means the outlets below. They are the English-language guitar publications that review new gear every month and print a score.
Premier Guitar, opens in a new tab
A monthly American guitar magazine and website, independently owned.
- Published by
- Gearhead Communications, Marion, Iowa
- How it scores
- Four ratings out of 5 on most reviews: Tones, Build Design, Ease of Use and Value, with a Pros box and a Cons box.
- On our desk
- 46 reviews
Guitar World, opens in a new tab
The largest American guitar magazine. Its website also runs reviews first printed in Guitarist and Total Guitar.
- Published by
- Future plc
- How it scores
- Stars out of 5, with a Pros list and a Cons list.
- On our desk
- 81 reviews
MusicRadar, opens in a new tab
A British music-gear website covering guitars, drums, synths and studio gear. We log its guitar reviews.
- Published by
- Future plc
- How it scores
- Stars out of 5, with a Pros list and a Cons list.
- On our desk
- 39 reviews
Guitar Player, opens in a new tab
The American guitar magazine founded in 1967, now published online.
- Published by
- Future plc
- How it scores
- Stars out of 5, with a Pros list and a Cons list.
- On our desk
- 16 reviews
Guitarist, opens in a new tab
A British monthly guitar magazine. Its reviews appear online on Guitar World, where we log them.
- Published by
- Future plc
- How it scores
- Stars out of 5, with a Pros list and a Cons list.
- On our desk
- 6 reviews
Guitar.com, opens in a new tab
A guitar website, successor to Guitar Magazine, published from London.
- Published by
- NME Networks
- How it scores
- A score out of 10.
- On our desk
- 42 reviews
They do the first half of the job, and we link every review so you can read it in full.
What we do to get to the truth
We log the review.
When one of the magazines reviews a pedal, amp or guitar, we record what it printed: the score, the price, the date, who wrote it, and the cons box word for word. Nothing is summarized and nothing is rounded.
We find the people who bought it.
We look where owners post in public: retailer review pages, the makers’ own forums and guitar forums. An owner report counts only when the person says they bought or own the gear. Members of our forum can add their own.
We read each quote at its source.
Every owner quote is copied from the page it was posted on and linked to that page. A quote we cannot open and read ourselves is left out. So are machine translations and posts written before the product shipped.
We compare claim by claim.
A review makes specific claims: it is quiet, it tracks well, the build is solid, it is worth the money. We set each claim beside what owners report about that same thing. Praise for one feature does not cancel a complaint about another.
We give one verdict.
Press was right, Split, or Fluffed. A piece of gear needs reports from at least 2 different owners before it gets a score. With fewer it is marked Too early and stays unscored until we have them.
We argue against ourselves, then fix mistakes.
Every full check in The Column prints a counterpoint that argues the opposite verdict as hard as it can, and readers vote on which side won. When a source changes or we got something wrong, we correct the row and date the change.
The four verdicts
- 12 on the desk
- Owners report what the review said they would. The praise held up and the cons box named the real drawbacks. We print this every time we find it.
- 9 on the desk
- Owners disagree with each other, or the review was right about the sound and missed something about living with the gear.
- 2 on the desk
- Owners report problems the review left out or played down: noise, failures, a missing feature, a price that does not match what arrived.
- 160 on the desk
- We have no owner report on file yet, or too few to call it. The review is listed with its score and cons box, and we check again as buyers post. Most new gear starts here.
What this cannot tell you
Owner reports have their own slant. People with a problem post more than people without one, and people who just spent money like to defend it. A handful of quotes is evidence, not a survey. That is why every row shows its sources and why thin evidence stays unscored.
Some large retailers and forums do not allow their pages to be read by software. We do not get around that, so a row can say no owner report is on file while buyers have posted somewhere we cannot quote. If you own the gear, the forum is the fastest way to fix that row.
We do not test gear ourselves on the Gear Desk, and a verdict judges the review, not the product. A pedal can be excellent and its review can still be fluffed.
Who pays for this
Suede Social carries no ads and no affiliate links. It sells nothing, so no verdict here earns us a commission. Suede funds it; its paid products live at suedeai.ai. The site is built and run by Jason Colapietro.
Where to go next
- The Gear Desk: 224 magazine reviews of 183 pieces of gear, each beside its owner reports.
- The Column: the full written check of one review at a time.
- The Fluff Index: the running score for each magazine and brand.
- Ask the forum: own something on the desk? Tell us how it held up.